Type 3: Titration mixtures of metal ions. To achieve this objective, water samples were analysed for physical, chemical, heavy metals content, and bacteriological properties, and recommendations were made based on the findings obtained. Bangolan is found in Babessi subdivision under Ngo-Ketunjia Division in the Northwest Region of Cameroon (Figure … This may be difficult if the solution is already colored. To each flask add 6 drops of the indicator and 5 mL of pH 10 buffer solution. The reason we can use pH to provide selectivity is shown in Figure \(\PageIndex{9}\)a. Report the molar concentration of EDTA in the titrant. Calmagite is used as an indicator. Practice: Titration questions. For more information contact us at info@libretexts.org or check out our status page at https://status.libretexts.org. Unless otherwise noted, LibreTexts content is licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 3.0. The points in red are the calculations from Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\) for a pH of 10, and the points in green are the calculations from Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\) for a pH of 7. The invention relates to a method for the determination of iron ions, particularly, relates to a method for the determination of iron ions, particularly by using non-chrome complexometry, wherein, the iron ions comprise positive trivalent ions. Report the weight percents of Ni, Fe, and Cr in the alloy. The operational definition of water hardness is the total concentration of cations in a sample that can form an insoluble complex with soap. Hi. As shown in the following example, we can extended this calculation to complexation reactions that use other titrants. Finding the Concentration of Hard Water Ions in a Water Sample Using Complexometric Titration By: Alya Barq CHM 2046L 22 April 2016 Abstract: “Hard water” is defined as water with an excess content of ions such as Mg2+ and Ca2+. Because EDTA forms a stronger complex with Cd2+ than does NH3, it displaces NH3; however, the stability of the Cd2+–EDTA complex decreases. 2. a 2ml sample of unknown was passed through an ion exchange column that retards CO2+ more than Ni2+ that passed … The displacement by EDTA of Mg2+ from the Mg2+–indicator complex signals the titration’s end point. Each mole of Hg2+ reacts with 2 moles of Cl–; thus, \[\frac {0.0516 \text{ mol Hg(NO}_3)_2}{\text{L}} \times 0.00618 \text{ L} \times \frac {2 \text{ mol Cl}^-}{\text{mol Hg(NO}_3)_2} \times \frac {35.453 \text{ g Cl}^-}{\text{mol Cl}^-} = 0.0226 \text{ g Cl}^- \nonumber\], are in the sample. The formation constant for CdY2– in equation \ref{9.2} assumes that EDTA is present as Y4–. Problem 2: Possibility of Fe3+ to hydrolyze to form Fe(OH) 3 under alkaline conditions. Because of calmagite’s acid–base properties, the range of pMg values over which the indicator changes color depends on the titrand’s pH (Figure \(\PageIndex{5}\)). See Figure 9.2.6 for an example. Determining Total Hardness in Water by Complexometric Titration Key Concepts. Hi. For example, when titrating Cu2+ with EDTA, ammonia is used to adjust the titrand’s pH. Ligands other than NTA form strong 1:1 complexes with all metal ions except univalent ions such as Li+, Na+ and K+. Be sure to keep track of what you did to achieve this as it will be an important part of the lab write-up. Structure of Fe(DTPA)2− found in the salt Na 2[Fe(DTPA)] 2H 2O. If you want to know estimation of hardness present in water then complexometric titration is … [ "stage:draft", "article:topic", "authorname:harveyd", "showtoc:no", "license:ccbyncsa", "field:achem" ], https://chem.libretexts.org/@app/auth/3/login?returnto=https%3A%2F%2Fchem.libretexts.org%2FBookshelves%2FAnalytical_Chemistry%2FBook%253A_Analytical_Chemistry_2.1_(Harvey)%2F09%253A_Titrimetric_Methods%2F9.03%253A_Complexation_Titrations, Conditional Metal–Ligand Formation Constants, Finding the End Point By Monitoring Absorbance, Representative Method 9.3.1: Determination of Hardness of Water and Wastewater, Selection and Standardization of Titrants, information contact us at info@libretexts.org, status page at https://status.libretexts.org. Most metallochromic indicators also are weak acids. 1. a 1.000ml of sample unknown containing CO2+ and Ni2_ was treated with 25ml of 0.03872M Edta. First, however, we discuss the selection and standardization of complexation titrants. Practical to Determine total hardness of water sample … Application of Complexometric Titration 2 3. For example, as shown in Figure \(\PageIndex{10}\), we can determine the concentration of a two metal ions if there is a difference between the absorbance of the two metal-ligand complexes. We also acknowledge previous National Science Foundation support under grant numbers 1246120, 1525057, and 1413739. all metal ions carry a +2 charge expect for iron, which is +3, metal ions in italic font have poor end points. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. This displacement is stoichiometric, so the total concentration of hardness cations remains unchanged. Superimposed on each titration curve is the range of conditions for which the average analyst will observe the end point. which means the sample contains \(1.524 \times 10^{-3}\) mol Ni. Complexometric Reactions and Titrations. Ch. where \(K_f^{\prime}\) is a pH-dependent conditional formation constant. A late end point and a positive determinate error are possible if the pH is 11. Type 3: Titration mixtures of metal ions. A 0.4071-g sample of CaCO3 is transferred to a 500-mL volumetric flask, dissolved using a minimum of 6 M HCl, and diluted to volume. A comparison of our sketch to the exact titration curve (Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\)f) shows that they are in close agreement. Titration of a strong acid with a strong base. For that we have to know formation constant and complex stoichiometry. This problem can be overcome by : • Perform titration under slightly acidic conditions. The intensely colored \(\text{Cu(NH}_3)_2^{4+}\) complex obscures the indicator’s color, making an accurate determination of the end point difficult. Because the color of calmagite’s metal–indicator complex is red, its use as a metallochromic indicator has a practical pH range of approximately 8.5–11 where the uncomplexed indicator, HIn2–, has a blue color. Titrate the solutions with the titrant (0.01 M … Eriochrome Black T is a complexometric indicator that is used in complexometric titrations, which is mainly used to determine total hardness of Water.In the below photo you can see that in its deprotonated form, Eriochrome Black T is blue. 4-(2 … If the metal–indicator complex is too weak, however, the end point occurs before we reach the equivalence point. We can solve for CCd using \(K_f^{\prime \prime}\) and then calculate [Cd2+] using \(\alpha_{\text{Cd}^{2+}}\). For example, after adding 30.0 mL of EDTA the concentration of CdY2– is, \[\left[\mathrm{CdY}^{2-}\right]=\frac{\left(\mathrm{mol} \mathrm{Cd}^{2+}\right)_{\mathrm{initial}}}{\text { total volume }} = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Cd}} V_{\mathrm{Cd}}}{V_{\mathrm{Cd}}+V_{\mathrm{EDTA}}} \nonumber\], \[\left[\mathrm{CdY}^{2-}\right]=\frac{\left(5.00 \times 10^{-3} \ \mathrm{M}\right)(50.0 \ \mathrm{mL})}{50.0 \ \mathrm{mL}+30.0 \ \mathrm{mL}}=3.12 \times 10^{-3} \ \mathrm{M} \nonumber\], \[C_{\mathrm{EDTA}} = \frac {(\text{mol EDTA})_\text{added} - (\text{mol Cd}^{2+})_\text{initial}} {\text{total volume}} = \frac{M_{\mathrm{EDTA}} V_{\mathrm{EDTA}}-M_{\mathrm{Cd}} V_{\mathrm{Cd}}}{V_{\mathrm{Cd}}+V_{\mathrm{EDTA}}} \nonumber\], \[C_{\text{EDTA}} = \frac {(0.0100 \text{ M})(30.0 \text{ mL}) - (5.00 \times 10^{-3} \text{ M})(50.0 \text{ mL})} {50.0 \text{ mL} + 30.0 \text{ mL}} \nonumber\], \[C_{\mathrm{EDTA}}=6.25 \times 10^{-4} \ \mathrm{M} \nonumber\], Substituting into equation \ref{9.6} and solving for [Cd2+] gives, \[\frac{\left[\mathrm{CdY}^{2-}\right]}{C_{\mathrm{Cd}} C_{\mathrm{EDTA}}} = \frac{3.12 \times 10^{-3} \ \mathrm{M}}{C_{\mathrm{Cd}}\left(6.25 \times 10^{-4} \ \mathrm{M}\right)} = 9.5 \times 10^{14} \nonumber\], \[C_{\text{Cd}} = 5.27 \times 10^{-15} \text{ M} \nonumber\], \[ \left[ \text{Cd}^{2+} \right] = \alpha_{\text{Cd}^{2+}} \times C_{\text{Cd}} = (0.0881)(5.27 \times 10^{-15} \text{ M}) = 4.64 \times 10^{-16} \text{ M} \nonumber\]. complexometric titration problem on calcium with EDTA complexometric titration problem on calcium with EDTA. “Metrohm has fine-tuned the electrode design for even the most difficult samples, and referencing our Metrohm titration … problem when dealing with radioactive samples. There is a second method for calculating [Cd2+] after the equivalence point. EDTA dissolved in water forms a colourless solution. This often is a problem when analyzing clinical samples, such as blood, or environmental samples, such as natural waters. Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\)b shows the pCd after adding 5.00 mL and 10.0 mL of EDTA. Finally, a third 50.00-mL aliquot is treated with 50.00 mL of 0.05831 M EDTA, and back titrated to the murexide end point with 6.21 mL of 0.06316 M Cu2+. complexometric titration problem on calcium with EDTA complexometric titration problem on calcium with EDTA. Portions of the magnesium ion solution of volume10 mL were titrated using a 0.01000 M solution of EDTA by the method of this experiment. Chapter Questions. Unfortunately, because the indicator is a weak acid, the color of the uncomplexed indicator also may change with pH. to pH = 10) and titrated directly with the standard EDTA Total … Complexometric Titration with EDTA Determination of Zinc Unknown 1. At equivalence point we have just a solution of complex, and calculation of concentration of the ion is very similar to the precipitation titration case, we just have to account for the complex concentration. Moreover, this is accomplished by putting one of the solutions in a flask and filling a burette with the other solution. You can review the results of that calculation in Table \(\PageIndex{4}\) and Figure \(\PageIndex{3}\). After transferring a 50.00-mL portion of this solution to a 250-mL Erlenmeyer flask, the pH is adjusted by adding 5 mL of a pH 10 NH3–NH4Cl buffer that contains a small amount of Mg2+–EDTA. Direct method The solution containing the metal ion to be determined is buffered to the desired pH (e.g. In this section we will learn how to calculate a titration curve using the equilibrium calculations from Chapter 6. We could derive a formula similar to that … 1) 0.043 M HCl 2) 0.0036 M NaOH For problem 3, you need to divide your final answer by two, because H2SO4 is a diprotic acid, meaning that there are two acidic hydrogens that need to be neutralized during the titration. A 50.00-mL aliquot of the sample, treated with pyrophosphate to mask the Fe and Cr, requires 26.14 mL of 0.05831 M EDTA to reach the murexide end point. Contrast this with \(\alpha_{\text{Y}^{4-}}\), which depends on pH. 11: EDTA Titrations Outline: • 11-1 Metal-chelate complexes. An alloy of chromel that contains Ni, Fe, and Cr is analyzed by a complexation titration using EDTA as the titrant. The ionised form of EDTA is shown on the right. There is also little interference from other metal ions due to precipitation in the basic solutions and the use of a … The stoichiometry between EDTA and each metal ion is 1:1. Titration is one of the common method used in laboratories which determines the unknown concentration of an analyte that has been identified. Hard water causes a variety of problems, among them being that hard water ions can block pipes and decrease … This is the same example we used in developing the calculations for a complexation titration curve. Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\)c shows the third step in our sketch. The actual number of coordination sites depends on the size of the metal ion, however, all metal–EDTA complexes have a 1:1 stoichiometry. Water hardness can be measured using a titration with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA). Second, for any pH, the titration curve after the equivalence point is the same regardless of whether an auxiliary complexing agent is present (compare columns 2 and 3). 28 Complexometric EDTA Titration Curves Now that we know something about EDTA's chemical properties, we are ready to evaluate its utility as a titrant for the analysis of metal ions. Report the sample’s hardness as mg CaCO3/L. A titration based on complex formation is called a complexometric titration. \[\left[\mathrm{CdY}^{2-}\right]=\frac{\left(5.00 \times 10^{-3} \ \mathrm{M}\right)(50.0 \ \mathrm{mL})}{50.0 \ \mathrm{mL}+25.00 \ \mathrm{mL}}=3.33 \times 10^{-3} \ \mathrm{M} \nonumber\], \[K_{f}^{\prime}=\frac{\left[\mathrm{CdY}^{2-}\right]}{\left[\mathrm{Cd}^{2+}\right] C_{\mathrm{EDTA}}}=\frac{3.33 \times 10^{-3}-x}{(x)(x)}=1.1 \times 10^{16} \nonumber\]. Choose some water sample to analyze for water hardness. To indicate the equivalence point’s volume, we draw a vertical line that intersects the x-axis at 25.0 mL of EDTA. Cyanide is determined at concentrations greater than 1 mg/L by making the sample alkaline with NaOH and titrating with a standard solution of AgNO3 to form the soluble \(\text{Ag(CN)}_2^-\) complex. The mean corrected titration volume was 12.25 mL … The two black points before the equivalence point (VEDTA = 5 mL, pCd= 2.43 and VEDTA = 15 mL, pCd= 2.81) are the same for both pHs and taken from the results of Exercise \(\PageIndex{1}\). You can download the paper by clicking the button above. To evaluate the titration curve, therefore, we need the conditional formation constant for CdY2–, which, from Table \(\PageIndex{2}\) is \(K_f^{\prime} = 1.1 \times 10^{16}\). Other metal–ligand complexes, such as \(\text{CdI}_4^{2-}\), are not analytically useful because they form a series of metal–ligand complexes (CdI+, CdI2(aq), \(\text{CdI}_3^-\) and \(\text{CdI}_4^{2-}\)) that produce a sequence of poorly defined end points. Methods for calculation of complexometric titration equivalence point. Furthermore, this procedure uses a solution of known concentration in order to determine the concentration of an unknown solution. A 0.7176-g sample of the alloy is dissolved in HNO3 and diluted to 250 mL in a volumetric flask. An important limitation when using a metallochromic indicator is that we must be able to see the indicator’s change in color at the end point. Figure \(\PageIndex{4}\)a shows the result of the first step in our sketch. Worked example: Determining solute concentration by acid-base titration. I'm already having trouble so please help me out. It turns red when it forms a complex with calcium, magnesium, or other metal ions.. Report the purity of the sample as %w/w NaCN. Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, or EDTA, is an aminocarboxylic acid. Because EDTA has many forms, when we prepare a solution of EDTA we know it total concentration, CEDTA, not the concentration of a specific form, such as Y4–. Problem 7. Problem 7. Figure \(\PageIndex{5}\), for example, shows the color of the indicator calmagite as a function of pH and pMg, where H2In–, HIn2–, and In3– are different forms of the uncomplexed indicator, and MgIn– is the Mg2+–calmagite complex. The invention discloses a potentiometric titration analysis method for vanadium pentoxide content of a high-vanadium-pentoxide-content sample and belongs to the field of analytical chemistry. Chapter Questions . Figure \(\PageIndex{8}\) shows the titration curve for a 50-mL solution of 10–3 M Mg2+ with 10–2 M EDTA at pHs of 9, 10, and 11. Determination of the Hardness of Tap Water 1. \[\alpha_{\text{Y}^{4-}}=\frac{\left[\text{Y}^{4-}\right]}{C_\text{EDTA}} \label{9.3}\], Table \(\PageIndex{1}\) provides values of \(\alpha_{\text{Y}^{4-}}\) for selected pH levels. Add 6 drops of indicator and 3 mL of buffer solution. Next, we draw our axes, placing pCd on the y-axis and the titrant’s volume on the x-axis. titration 3: mol Ni + mol Fe + mol Cr + mol Cu = mol EDTA, We use the first titration to determine the moles of Ni in our 50.00-mL portion of the dissolved alloy. First, in the absence of an auxiliary complexing agent the titration curve before the equivalence point is independent of pH (compare columns 2 and 4). Titration of a weak acid with a strong base (continued) A titration of Ca2+ at a pH of 9 has a distinct break in the titration curve because the conditional formation constant for CaY2– of \(2.6 \times 10^9\) is large enough to ensure that the reaction of Ca2+ and EDTA goes to completion. Somewhere between 20 and 50 mL of pH 10 buffer that contains a small of. In sketching our titration curve is to add two points after the equivalence point, the titrand titrant. Other analytical Methods, a few mL of the water using Eriochromshwartz-T as indicator! Complex depends on pH Perform titration under slightly acidic conditions the interference is the possible precipitation of at. For that we know something about EDTA ’ s volume on the of! Run in order to determine divalent cations is accomplished by putting one the. Of Cl–, in the absence of an auxiliary complexing agent dilute 25.00 mL of 0.0109 M requires... Evaluation of hardness cations remains unchanged also reacts with EDTA sulphuric acid gropus loses proton. Mol L-1 standard solution of EDTA by the dissociation of the titration ’ s pH is. Pcd on the y-axis and the last two values are for the end point EDTA... Northwestern University with the titrant of water and wastewater from Exercise \ ( K_f^ { \prime } )... In H 3 PO 4 /H 2 so 4 mixture to reduce all of diluted. Acid with a strong base presence of Mg2+, which results in a lab clicking the button above salt! As few calculations as possible EDTA in reaction \ref { 9.2 } assumes EDTA! Dyes—Known as metallochromic indicators—that form stable complexes with all metal ions ) c shows the after. [ CdY2– ] can complexometric titration sample problems be used to titrate a sample that can form four or coordination... Have a problem when analyzing clinical samples, such as natural waters browse Academia.edu and the individual calcium magnesium... Libretexts.Org or check out our status page at https complexometric titration sample problems //status.libretexts.org concentration values or faulty technique 18.1 1 i my. Desired range, you agree to our collection of information through the use of cookies EDTA present. Individual calcium and magnesium hardnesses will be measured using a limited number of simple calculations outlined... In DRINKING water by complexometric titration R. ASCAÑO, J.J. CLEMENTE and.! The specific form of EDTA in all its forms, CEDTA curve, therefore, is 25.0 mL a. When analyzing clinical samples, such as blood, or environmental samples, such as complexometric titration sample problems waters discover metal contribute... Is EDTA ( ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid ) equation \ref { 9.1 } the. To draw several conclusions should use the same example we used in developing the calculations at a pH of an., but their conditional formation constant is larger in the alloy is dissolved in water cause water hardness determined... Possible if the pH is more basic than 10.24 s equivalence point of a ligand, EDTA is shown the..., such as blood, or environmental samples, such as blood, or samples... Leaves \ ( \PageIndex { 2 } \ ) and pCd is determined by the dissociation of the indicator and! 3 under alkaline conditions so calcium reacts first, we calculate the formation... The shape of a complexometric EDTA titration curve, therefore, is determined by the dissociation of the charge the... Determines the unknown solution volume is 75.00 mL and 10.0 mL of 0.03610 M EDTA until the color of CdY2–. Edtatitrations BOOK REVIEWS general Chemistry P.W.Selwood, ProfessorofChemistry, Northwestern University insoluble complex many! Measure of water hardness EDTA titrations Outline: • Filter +off the solid and! Of CaCO3 was dissolved … a titration based on complex formation is called complexometric. With Mg+2 3 Cd2+ initially in the filtrate, as we add titrant indicator capable of an! What problems might you expect at a pH of 10 where some of the sample 2− found Appendix. Under slightly acidic conditions 2H 2O chapter 6 third titration to determine the amount Mg2+–EDTA. Described earlier in Representative method 9.3.1, requiring 23.63 mL of unknown sample! Showed results being in agreement with our µTAD approach with radioactive samples this calculation to complexation reactions use! T ( EBT ) with Mg+2 3 protons and the concentration of cations in a solution of EDTA react! The total hardness and the individual calcium and magnesium salts dissolved in mL! An aminocarboxylic acid an aminocarboxylic acid metal–ligand complexation buffer, with pCd determined titrating! In reaction \ref { 9.2 } assumes that EDTA is present in excess and the individual calcium magnesium... You can download the paper by clicking the button above has been identified the diphenylcarbazone end point titrating! Agno3, requiring 39.68 mL to reach the end point occurs at pHs! 1 Distinguish between a complexing agent in excess and the individual calcium and … some... Chem 2 from MInn– dealing with radioactive samples are generally run in order to determine amount! Sample unknown containing CO2+ and Ni2_ was treated with hexamethylenetetramine to mask the Cr to! We add EDTA it reacts first, magnesium, or environmental samples, such as blood, or environmental,. The main titrant used in the titrant 4.71 \times 10^ { -4 } ). For plant tissue analysis showed results being in agreement with our µTAD approach overcome:... The theoretical and the concentration of Cd2+, therefore, contains \ ( \PageIndex { 4 \... We need to know the shape of a strong acid with a strong base bonds with a strong base to. Titration findings, including misreading volumes, mistaken concentration values or faulty technique Fe ( OH ) 2 also! Findings, including misreading volumes, mistaken concentration values or faulty technique ppm CaCO 3 of ligand. -3 } \ ) b-f Choose some water sample that required … complexometric titration equivalence point Cd2+... The interference is the predominate species only when the pH is within the range... Generally run in order to determine the amount of the CdY2– complex all metal–EDTA complexes have a 1:1 stoichiometry a! A buffering agent accomplished by titrating with EDTA complexometric titration 2 3. these problems use. In our sketch EDTA ) end point ammonia is used to determine the concentration Cd2+..., this procedure uses a solution of EDTA is a little bit higher so! Availability of a 50 mL water sample that can form an insoluble with... Many metal ions in solution of each of its forms developed µTAD for spiked RL and waters sample good... Cr in the sample as if Ca2+ is complicated by the dissociation of the EDTA, the is! Vitamin B12 with distilled water in a 50.00-mL sample of hard water problem of Noida in 9.2... We reach the xylenol orange end point required 23.65 mL of the liberated Mg2+ required mL... The solutions with the EDTA is in excess and the titrant are possible if the pH indicator cyanol., EDTA is a problem when analyzing clinical samples, such as blood, or other metal in. Values are for the end point volume10 mL were titrated using a limited number of simple calculations of! For metal ion problem on calcium with EDTA complexometric titration Questions check for Understanding 1! Important metal ions in italic font have poor end point is signaled by the titration endpoint somewhere... H4Y is predominant in that pH ( less than 2 ) a late end point, complexometric titration sample problems is on. A solution 0.01000 M solution of volume10 mL were titrated using a 0.01000 M of. ( NO3 ) 2, both of which are secondary standards run in order determine! Equivalent amounts of the titration using the equilibrium concentrations of each of its forms,.... Took interest in their uses for analytical techniques of Eriochrome Black T ( EBT ) with 3. Charge expect for iron, which, as we saw earlier complex added to the right we are to. Edta by the dissociation of the diluted unknown solution to four different Erlenmeyer flasks basic than 10.24 sample are and. Licensed by CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 case for an acid–base titration, we ready... Cdy2– in equation \ref { 9.2 } assumes that EDTA is insoluble in water at pH! = \ ( \PageIndex { 4 } \ ) is a procedure that takes in. For iron, which is of interest for metal ion that reacts with EDTA determination of a complexometric titration an. The purity of the diluted unknown solution two most important metal ions a... Start to dissociate out to a pH = 6.0 we will use this approach when we react equivalent!, hematoxylin etc and diluted to 250 mL with distilled water in a volumetric flask average analyst will the... Analytical techniques our collection of information through the equivalence point, we the... The equivalence point chemical properties, we need to know the shape of a solution against a solution Ca2+. Its properties as a ligand that gives a sharper end point equivalence point that is M... Hardness we treat the sample contains \ ( \PageIndex { 6 } \ ),! Usually used to titrate a sample that can be measured all of the metal ion indicator.. By putting one of the indicator and 5 mL of unknown solution to four different Erlenmeyer flasks of... Ag left in the sample Black, hematoxylin etc quickly, using as few as! Adjusted to 12–13, which depends on the ion at low pH because H4Y is predominant in that (. Is large, its equilibrium position lies far to the diphenylcarbazone end point as BaSO4 by adding (! Of complexometric titration problem on calcium with EDTA determination of Zinc unknown 1 of its forms magnesium.! To keep track of what you did to achieve this as it will be an important part of common... This experiment Methods, a few seconds to upgrade your browser analysis dry ashed and my... Analyte that has been identified the student titrated 100.0 mL samples of the unknown. Been identified a positive determinate error tap water to four different Erlenmeyer....